TY - JOUR
T1 - Co-Designing Evidence-Based Videos in Health Care
T2 - A Case Exemplar of Developing Creative Knowledge Translation “Evidence-Experience” Resources
AU - Archibald, Mandy
AU - Ambagtsheer, Rachel
AU - Lawless, Michael T.
AU - Thompson, Mark O.
AU - Shultz, Timothy
AU - Chehade, Mellick J.
AU - Whiteway, Lyn
AU - Sheppard, Anna
AU - Plaza, Maria Pinero de
AU - Kitson, Alison L.
N1 - Funding Information:
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: MA was supported during the tenure of the video development by a Canadian Institutes of Health Research Fellowship and fellowship support from the Centre of Research Excellence in Frailty and Healthy Ageing. The initial video development was supported through a G-TRAC Resthaven research grant.
Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2021.
PY - 2021
Y1 - 2021
N2 - Objective: Well-designed evidence-based resources that reflect participant experiences and priorities are imperative for informed consumer health decision-making and to combat the pervasive health misinformation existing today. Qualitative research data can inform the development of such resources, but the process of reconciling qualitative research data with other sources of evidence through co-design processes is not well described in the literature. In response to the need for such evidence-based materials and corresponding methodological guidance, we co-designed a series of video resources through transdisciplinary and community partnership. In this manuscript, we provide methodological insight into the process of collaborative co-design to improve the utilization of qualitative research evidence into evidence-based resources for the public. Methods: Following from a large qualitative research study, we engaged in a collaborative and creative co-design process involving a multi-stakeholder advisory group guided by Boyd's co-design framework. We explicate this process, drawing from a case exemplar of transdisci-plinary frailty research. Results: We utilized thematic qualitative data to co-produce: (i) an animation, (ii) a documentary-style video, (iii) a video vignette with key messages embedded in narratives of older adults, and (iv) a key-message video delivered by academic health researchers and clinicians. Discussion: The integration of experiential evidence of health care consumers with other sources of research evidence through co-design is an epistemological and procedural challenge with potential to improve public awareness, knowledge, and to support evidence-based decision making. Keywords arts based methods, case study, focus groups, interpretive description, methods in qualitative inquiry, mixed methods, virtual environments
AB - Objective: Well-designed evidence-based resources that reflect participant experiences and priorities are imperative for informed consumer health decision-making and to combat the pervasive health misinformation existing today. Qualitative research data can inform the development of such resources, but the process of reconciling qualitative research data with other sources of evidence through co-design processes is not well described in the literature. In response to the need for such evidence-based materials and corresponding methodological guidance, we co-designed a series of video resources through transdisciplinary and community partnership. In this manuscript, we provide methodological insight into the process of collaborative co-design to improve the utilization of qualitative research evidence into evidence-based resources for the public. Methods: Following from a large qualitative research study, we engaged in a collaborative and creative co-design process involving a multi-stakeholder advisory group guided by Boyd's co-design framework. We explicate this process, drawing from a case exemplar of transdisci-plinary frailty research. Results: We utilized thematic qualitative data to co-produce: (i) an animation, (ii) a documentary-style video, (iii) a video vignette with key messages embedded in narratives of older adults, and (iv) a key-message video delivered by academic health researchers and clinicians. Discussion: The integration of experiential evidence of health care consumers with other sources of research evidence through co-design is an epistemological and procedural challenge with potential to improve public awareness, knowledge, and to support evidence-based decision making. Keywords arts based methods, case study, focus groups, interpretive description, methods in qualitative inquiry, mixed methods, virtual environments
KW - arts based methods
KW - case study
KW - focus groups
KW - interpretive description
KW - methods in qualitative inquiry
KW - mixed methods
KW - virtual environments
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85111880459&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - https://doi.org/10.25905/21424635.v1
U2 - 10.1177/16094069211019623
DO - 10.1177/16094069211019623
M3 - Article
SN - 1609-4069
VL - 20
SP - 1
EP - 10
JO - International Journal of Qualitative Methods
JF - International Journal of Qualitative Methods
ER -